FINAL UPDATE: Annual Town Meeting is Underway
Check back throughout the day Saturday for updates on Town Meeting proceedings.
Editor's Note: Check back throughout the day for updates on Wilmington's Annual Town Meeting.
It took just about 30 minutes after the scheduled 10:30 a.m. start time, but Annual Town Meeting is underway as of 10:56 a.m. now that the necessary quorum of 150 residents is in attendance.
The Wilmington Minutemen presented the colors before marching out of the Wilmington High School gymnasium to a round of applause.
Town Moderator James Stewart is running through the rules now voters are now hearing a reading of Article 1.
Updated at 11:29 a.m.: Voters have approved General Government and Public Safety budgets so far as a part of Article 1, though there were two residents who expressed concerns with increases.
"I can't imagine anybody increasing salary this much during these fiscal times," said one Woburn Street resident. "When you look at the regular business world, there are normal increases of about 2 to 3 percent. I don't know why we're increasing so much."
The General Government budget of $1,949,538 was approved by a wide margin.
Kevin MacDonald stepped to the microphone during the Public Safety debate and said he believes the line items for the Police Department are excessive, and questioned the salary Police Chief Michael Begonis earns.
"It's my believe the department is overstaffed," said MacDonald. "I disagree that we should have to pay overtime, and I'd like to strike any and all overtime pay from this budget for the Police Department."
That motion was deemed not allowable, and the budget passed.
Updated at 11:44 a.m.: MacDonald made an ammendment to take $194,460 that was scheduled to be alloted in the Department of Public Works budget for sand and salt, and pay for it out of free cash instead.
The motion failed without any votes in favor, and that portion of the budget was approved.
Updated at 12:16 p.m.: During the School Department budget discussion, MacDonald asked how much Superintendent of Schools Joanne Benton's salary is.
School Committee chiarman Margaret Kane answered that Benton currently makes about $170,000, but the negotiations for next year's salary have not begun.
MacDonald moved to restrict Benton's salary to $100,000, a move that was deemed against rules.
Article 5, which is the budget as a whole, passed.
Following the completition of that article, Stewart saluted retiring Town Manager Michael Caira for his 31 years of work at Town Meeting, to which he received a standing ovation. We're now on to Article 6.
Updated at 12:37 p.m.: Article 6 was just approved by residents, which authorizes the town to purchase four replacement police cruisers, one pumper for the Fire Department and one repleacement vacuum street sweeper and one replacement backhoe and loader.
MacDonald proposed an ammendment to the DPW purchase that would require the vehicles to be manufactured in America. That motion was defeated by the body and Article 7 is now up for discussion.
Before moving on, Stewart joked, "I'll make the most important announcement of the day, and that's that pizza is here."
Updated at 12:52 p.m.: Articles 7, 8 and 9, passed without much objection.
One resident asked the moderator if it was appropriate for MacDonald to question "minute details" of each article.
"Democracy is not without pain," joked Stewart who also added that it is not out of order to speak on each article, unless the moderator determines it is a deliberate attempt to slow down the process. "My job is to make sure people stay on point. It's a fine line and I am doing the best that I can."
Updated at 1:13 p.m.: All articles were approved related to the budget, so Articles 1-17 were taken and voted on in order. The following articles will be drawn randomly for the order they'll be spoken upon.
The first item drawn was Kevin MacDonald's petitioned Article 32, seeking to rescind the vote taken at Special Town Meeting in December when residents soundly approved a new high school.
After conferring with Town Counsel, Stewart ruled that the article is out of order. However, Stewart allowed an appeal by MacDonald that will now go in front of the body. MacDonald is making his case to his fellow voters.
Updated at 1:31 p.m.: MacDonald's amendment failed and thus his article was deemed out of order.
His petitioned Article 31 to establish a town website to collaborate on ideas is up for discussion now.
While arguing for his article, MacDonald said by having a website where residents can express concerns, there would be less empty seats at Town Meeting. Town Manager Michael Caira had a pointed response.
"This is just a waste of everyone's time and I found it interesting that the maker of this motion is attributing as to why these seats are not filled," said Caira. "I think all of you folks know why these seats are not filled."
Updated at 2:02 p.m.: Resident George Lingenfelter's motion regarding fence bylaws in town was discussed for about 30 minutes before it was eventually defeated by an 84-39 count.
Mark Nelson's Article 37 is the next item up for discussion.
Updated at 2:29 p.m.: The first of two petitioned articles by Mark Nelson, Article 37, failed by a 72-15 count. That item dealt with adjusting the town map, as does Article 38.
But first up for discussion is Kevin MacDonald's Article 36 dealing with the Stormwater Management Plan.
That debate lasted less than two minutes, and the article was soundly defeated. Article 25, petitioned by Craig Newhouse, is up next. But the article was passed over.
Updated at 2:54 p.m.: After another one of MacDonald's articles seeking to overturn the high school vote was ruled out of order, the purchase of Yentile's Farm through free cash is now up for debate with selectman Michael Newhouse at the microphone.
"It makes sense for the town to use free cash for purposes just like this one, one time opportunities," said Newhouse. "That’s why we maintain positive cash reserve to take advantages of opportnities like this. This is a good time to invest in real estate in general."
Updated at 3:05 p.m.: Residents soundly approve the purchase of the 9 Cross Street property, and do so without any opposition. The official count of the approval is a unanimous 122-0.
Updated at 3:29 p.m.: Though the crowd has dwindled, there are still 10 articles remaining. Kevin MacDonald is again speaking on his latest petitioned article, but this was his last trip to the microphone.
After Stewart made a ruling, MacDonald responded with, "Thank you, Mr. Stewart, for telling me something I already knew."
"I try to deal with people as respectfull as possible," said Stewart. "But there is a limit to my patience, and I just got there. Mr. MacDonald, it's over. Enough. Chief, please get him out of here."
Updated at 4:00 p.m.: There are five articles remaining on the docket. Currently, residents and officials are discussing Article 27, related to town employees serving in the United States Armed Forces.
Updated at 4:18 p.m.: After lengthy discussion, Article 27 was approved by the remaining residents.
The next up for discussion is Article 20, which asks to approve new bylaws that would use fines as penalty for trespassing instead of putting a mark on their criminal record.
The article passed soundly.
Updated at 4:37 p.m.: Mark Nelson is now disussing his second petitioned article, which seeks to add Polk Street to the official town map. This is one of three remaining articles to come before the remaining voters.
FINAL UPDATE at 4:48 p.m.: Town Moderator James Stewart just made the motion to adjourn, and voters gladly approved.
"This was a difficult meeting for me and for many of you as well," said Stewart. "I appreciate your patience."
Thanks for following along with today's coverage, and check back with Wilmington Patch on Monday for more on Town Meeting.
Nick M.
7:37 pm on Saturday, May 5, 2012
"This is just a waste of everyone's time and I found it interesting that the maker of this motion is attributing as to why these seats are not filled," said Caira. "I think all of you folks know why these seats are not filled."
Thank you Mr. Caira. This is exactly why I do not attend the Town Meetings. I do not have the luxury to spend my entire Saturday listening to the constant rantings of basically one disgruntled resident. I with there was something that could be done to curb this behavior, but as Mr. Stewart stated "Democracy is not without pain."
I didn't realize Mr. Caira was retiring. Thank you sir for your years of service with the town.
Kevin MacDonald
10:38 pm on Saturday, May 5, 2012
The Town budget when Mr. Caira became manager was $33,344,490. The fiscal year budget for 2013 is now $86,430,144. The increase just from fiscal year 2012 to 2013 is an increase of $6,560,259.
$86,430,144
- $33,344,490
_______________
$53,085,654 budget increase since Caira took over
Question: If this was the private sector would he have been fired by now?
Question: Mr. Mollo, Do you not have the luxury of spending your entire Saturday at Town Meeting because you don't care to fight against injustice and for what is right or is it because you have to work on Saturday to pay for your high taxes?
Kevin MacDonald
11:11 pm on Saturday, May 5, 2012
State of Massachusetts mean salary $53,700
Governor's annual salary $140,535
Wilmington school superintendent Joanne Benton $170,000
I do not believe that she has a doctorate in education
49% of the eighth graders at the middle school are in the warning or needs improvement category in mathematics as was reported at a school committee meeting.
Question: Is there something wrong with this picture?
Question: Would it be fair to say that the employees vote for each others pay raises at Town Meeting and get away with it because there is too much apathy in Wilmington regarding fiscal matters?
Go to this website: http://msn.careerbuilder.com/Article/MSN-2761-Salaries-Promotions-Whos-earning-more-than-your-governor/
Christine
9:21 pm on Sunday, May 6, 2012
I heard enough out of you Kev on Sat to last me all year and then some..your paranoia that everyone's out for your money is worrisome-- YOU DO NOT SPEAK FOR ME or for most of the town by the looks of people who voted for you--I don't need your "protection" against the evil town manager, or "overpaid" police.. Frankly, YOU wasted more of my time Saturday with your nonsense than the town has wasted in the entire time I've lived here.. If we're apathetic--it's STILL not your job to usurp the democratic process by speaking nonsense on every article for 7 hours-- If you want to improve the schools and our children's lives there are better ways, and the BEST way is to live by example--this includes being respectful of MY time and your fellow hardworking townspeople...hopefully, others will speak up here too..
Nick M.
9:53 pm on Sunday, May 6, 2012
Actually Mr. MacDonald, I do not see injustices of which you speak, nor was I working to pay for my "high" taxes. I have a family with whom I wish to spend my time. If the meeting was only 3 or 4 hours (which it could be), it would be a different story. But when the meeting is drawn out for unnecessary reasons, I object. I can't afford to lose that personal time. That's not to say that I didn't take the time a few months ago to stand with the near unanimous voice of the town who WANTS to build a new high school.
Our budget may have gone up - so what? That's what happens, yes, even in the private sector (I work in the private sector, and it's a FACT). Our town is quite prosperous from what I understand. One of the reasons I chose to live in Wilmington is because of the great balance of taxes and services - such as a good school system. I personally do not see a problem.
I, like Christine, would also like to hear other speak up.
Kevin MacDonald
11:47 pm on Sunday, May 6, 2012
One reason the budget goes up is by over inflating costs then transferring the extra funds into the free cash reserves. This should be a crime. The sand and salt money surplus was put into the free cash reserve fund. The nit wits at Town Meeting, when given the opportunity to fund fiscal year 2013 salt and sand costs from the free cash fund, chose instead to tax themselves again to fund it. You say so what if the budget goes up? Would having the budget go down be such a terrible thing? If the school system is so great, why are 49% of the eighth graders in the warning or needs improvement category for mathematics? "Government isn't the solution,Government is the problem." Mr. Mollo, The Annual Town Meeting is once a year. There are 364 other days to spend with your family. Come down and speak against the wasteful spending and the over paid administrators so I don't have to. I believe you may find yourself having some extra money to do some nice things with your family. I believe your kids will respect you and learn more from you by your actions and responsibility than they do from the school system.
Robert Hayes
12:32 am on Monday, May 7, 2012
Mr. MacDonald: Just to put some of your comments about our schools IN CONTEXT:
- 50% of WILMINGTON's 8th graders earned a 'needs improvement' or 'warning/failing status' in mathematics. 48% of MASSACHUSETTS'S 8th graders earned a 'needs improvement' or 'warning/failing status' in mathematics. I'm obviously not satisfied with these results, but we're virtually at the STATE AVERAGE.
- $170,000 is A LOT of money. No doubt. But Superintendents make A LOT of money. At the time of her salary review last year, Wilmington's superintendent was paid less than her peers in many nearby communities, including -- but not limited to -- Andover, Bedford, Belmont, Beverly, Billerica, Chelmsford, Georgetown, Lexington, Lynnfield, Medford, Methuen, North Andover, Reading, Tewksbury, and Winchester. Regional schools weren't included in the comparison, but - for the record - Wilmington's Superintendent also makes less than her counterpart at the Shawsheen Tech.
- Here's a story that will drive you crazy: http://www.gloucestertimes.com/local/x2063029233/Regional-tech-schools-pay-hike-irks-Kirk/print
Melissa
8:52 am on Wednesday, May 9, 2012
- $170,000 is A LOT of money. No doubt. But Superintendents make A LOT of money. At the time of her salary review last year, Wilmington's superintendent was paid less than her peers in many nearby communities, including -- but not limited to -- Andover, Bedford, Belmont, Beverly, Billerica, Chelmsford, Georgetown, Lexington, Lynnfield, Medford, Methuen, North Andover, Reading, Tewksbury, and Winchester. Regional schools weren't included in the comparison, but - for the record - Wilmington's Superintendent also makes less than her counterpart at the Shawsheen Tech.
Good town comparisons - now what we should really do is take a look at those towns taxes and see how much they are paying and what services they DON'T get such as trash removal, some have to pay for bussing, and other ammenties that we get, etc. So when people say that Wilmington taxes are high then move to another town....see how much other people are paying and what you will be missing when you leave Wilmington. I am just happy my trash gets picked up and I don't have to spend my quality family time on the weekends going to the dump.
Oh and I did not attend the town meeting - why - because people make it unbearable to sit there for more than 1-2 hours. I suffered through it last year with the high school vote, but until the antics of people who have nothing better to do than to derail others make it not something I want to do. I didn't attend because I had to work - I did that Monday - Friday already.
Kevin MacDonald
8:09 am on Monday, May 7, 2012
Thank you Mr. Hayes, It would be good if we did not look so much at State average but rather recruited the best teachers possible. If their pay raises were contingent upon performance and results, you may see a big difference in scores. I think it would be good to post the position of school superintendent for $100,000 a year and see what candidates reply. Mrs. Benton could then decide if she wants to go up against these challengers for the position. I also think you and the rest of the school committee should elect a new chairperson for the board. I believe the chairperson sets the agenda. I have been denied being placed on the agenda. I wonder how many other people have also been denied. I also believe you and the other members owe it to the community to keep salaries from escalating out of control.
MEC
2:54 pm on Monday, May 7, 2012
Can someone tell me if the water is safe to drink in Wilmington! Also, What about the Poop smell???
MEC
2:58 pm on Monday, May 7, 2012
I'm new to wilmington....Looks like I need to attend the next town meeting!
Can anyone tell me if the water is safe to drink and also if we can do anything about the nasty smell in the air!!